Sourcing comparison · Paper & Packaging

Switching paper & packaging sourcing from China to Canada

$29,013estimated duty & fee savings per year at $100,000 of imports
Rates last verified November 7, 2026

Tariff & fee savings only, assuming equal product cost — your actual landed cost also depends on price and freight, which vary by supplier.

How the saving scales with your volume

linear · equal FOB
Annual import valueEstimated duty & fee savings / year
$50,000$14,506
$250,000$72,531
$1,000,000$290,125

Savings scale linearly with volume. Enter your exact figure to model it.

Calculate your exact volume →

The two tariff stacks, side by side

on a fixed reference customs value
ChinaCurrent source
Section 30125%
Forced-labor S30112.5%
MPF$36.55
HMF$13.19
Total duties & fees$4,005.99
CanadaCheaper
Section 3010%
Forced-labor S30110%
MPF$36.55
HMF$13.19
Total duties & fees$1,104.74

When paper & packaging crosses a US border, where it was made now decides a surprising share of what it costs. Canada's 10% effective rate undercuts China's 37.5% by enough to free roughly $29,013 a year at $100,000 of volume. The duty line moves with paperwork, not production cost, which is why it rewards attention. The sections that follow show where every dollar of the difference comes from.

On the Canada side, 66 of the 388 paper & packaging lines owe an extra 50% under Section 338 (11 under HTSUS 9903.03.12 and 55 under HTSUS 9903.03.14). The Canada figure on this page leaves it out, so for those lines the gap to China is wider than shown.

How the tariff stacks compare

Start with the two duty stacks side by side. From China, the entry is assessed a 25% Section 301 surcharge and a 12.5% forced-labor Section 301 duty on its paper & packaging, an effective 37.5% once the $49.74 in processing fees are added. A Canada origin attracts a 10% forced-labor Section 301 duty on its paper & packaging, an effective 10% once the $49.74 in processing fees are added. The decisive layer is Section 301: a 25% surcharge that applies only to China-origin goods and sits on top of every other duty, which is why China routes run expensive across so many categories. The Merchandise Processing Fee and Harbor Maintenance Fee are charged on customs value, not origin, so they sit at $49.74 on either stack and never contribute to the gap. That leaves a $2,901.25 gap on every $10,000 of goods, driven entirely by the 27.5% spread in effective duty rate. That same per-dollar gap is about $7,253 on a $25,000 order and $29,013 on $100,000 of annual volume. Scaled to a single $25,000 PO, the gap is near $7,253, repeated on every reorder.

Trade context

The category, HTS 47, 48, 49, takes in Corrugated cardboard, Kraft paper, Coated printing paper, Paper bags, Labels, Tissue paper, and Carton boxes among other paper & packaging. Because paper & packaging moves in volume, even a modest per-unit duty gap aggregates into a number that decides sourcing strategy. On the pricing side, paper and packaging tariffs affect e-commerce logistics costs and retail packaging; US paper mills compete with lower-cost imports from Canada and Asia. China's trade profile leans toward consumer electronics, computers servers, and clothing garments, and it sits in Asia-Pacific. With no preferential deal in force, China paper & packaging faces the standard rates plus any applicable surcharge. A North America supplier, Canada concentrates its US exports in crude oil petroleum, passenger vehicles, and lumber wood products. USMCA lets compliant Canada paper & packaging skip the duty stack other origins pay (USMCA 0%, except Section 338 annex goods), provided rules of origin are satisfied. Spanning Asia-Pacific and North America, the two lanes differ in freight and transit, so weigh those against the duty saving. The recommendation is filtered to feasible suppliers, so Canada appears because it plausibly makes paper & packaging, not merely because its rate is low. Because surcharges have stacked rates well above their statutory base, country of origin has become a first-order cost driver for paper & packaging rather than a footnote.

Recommendation

Where Canada is a viable supplier, expect roughly $29,013 at $100,000, rising to about $72,531 at $250,000 and $290,125 at $1,000,000 as volume grows. These are engine-computed stacks, not estimates: identical inputs on both sides except country of origin, so the gap is purely a duty result. These figures reflect tariff and fee savings only, assuming equal product cost — your actual landed cost also depends on price and freight, which vary by supplier. Read the $29,013 as a transition budget — if re-sourcing to Canada costs less than the annual saving, it pays back inside a year. Diligence on Canada is commercial, not regulatory: supplier capacity, MOQ, tooling and re-qualification cost — the duty advantage itself is already settled above. Because rates move, treat this as a point-in-time read and re-check before committing — new proclamations and bilateral deals can shift the stack with little notice. Use the Tariff Savings Finder to test your real numbers and see alternatives beyond Canada.

Frequently Asked Questions

At $100,000 of annual import value, switching from China to Canada saves an estimated $29,013 in duties and fees, because the effective tariff rate falls from 37.5% to 10%. The saving scales linearly with volume. These figures reflect tariff and fee savings only, assuming equal product cost — your actual landed cost also depends on price and freight, which vary by supplier.

Canada-origin paper & packaging is assessed a 10% forced-labor Section 301 duty, for an effective 10% duty rate before the Merchandise Processing Fee ($36.55) and Harbor Maintenance Fee ($13.19).

China carries an effective 37.5% rate versus 10% for Canada. The gap is driven mainly by the 25% Section 301 surcharge that applies to Chinese-origin goods and stacks on top of every other layer.

Disclaimer: CalcMyTariff.com provides tariff estimates for informational purposes only. Actual duty rates depend on the specific HTS classification of your goods, which requires professional customs brokerage expertise. Rates shown reflect our best interpretation of currently published tariff schedules and may not include all applicable duties, anti-dumping duties, countervailing duties, or special tariffs. Consult a licensed US customs broker for binding determinations. Tariff rates change frequently — verify current rates with CBP or USITC before making import decisions.

Tariff rates from Tax Foundation, USITC, and Penn Wharton Budget Model; retaliatory data from the retaliating governments' official gazettes and registers; industry data from the U.S. Census Bureau (NAICS). Last verified .